Buying Guides

Most Reliable Used Cars UK 2026: Real Survey Results

The most reliable car brands and models in the UK in 2026, from the What Car? survey and the Warrantywise index, plus older cars, J.D. Power and ADAC.

By the Carhealth Editorial TeamUpdated 15+ min read

FREE INSTANT CHECK

Cheap car? Check it free before you buy.

Clocking is rife. Verify the mileage against MOT records free. Full history.

Free instant check · Not happy? We will refund you

The Short Answer

In the 2026 What Car? Reliability Survey, published in autumn 2026, Suzuki is the most reliable car brand in the UK with a score of 97.8%, ahead of Honda (95.8%) and Mini (95.4%). The Mini Countryman (2024 onwards) and the Suzuki Swift (2017-2024) share the top spot among individual models, both on 100%, according to What Car?'s model results.

For cars that are three to 15 years old, the Warrantywise Used Vehicle Reliability Index 2026 puts the Toyota Yaris first (89.2 out of 100), then the Kia Picanto (86.8) and the Toyota Aygo (83.8).

Those are the two best UK sources, and they measure different things on different cars. The rest of this guide shows both in full, explains where they disagree, and covers J.D. Power, ADAC and MOT data.

Key Takeaways

  • Best brand (cars up to five years old): Suzuki, 97.8% in the 2026 What Car? survey. Honda and Mini follow.
  • Best models: Mini Countryman and Suzuki Swift, both 100% in What Car?'s 2026 results. The Toyota Yaris leads the Warrantywise index for older cars.
  • Worst model in the 2026 What Car? survey: the Volkswagen Tiguan (2024 onwards) on 55.3%.
  • J.D. Power: there is no 2026 UK reliability study that we can find. The last UK edition we found was published in 2019. The 2026 study is US-only.
  • The sources disagree on purpose. Owner surveys, warranty claims and roadside breakdowns count different things, so use them together.
  • Check the actual car. A model's score tells you about the average car. The MOT history, service records, recalls and history check tell you about the one you are viewing.

Most Reliable Car Brands UK 2026 (What Car?)

The What Car? survey ranks 30 brands. These are the top 10 and the bottom five for cars up to five years old.

PositionBrandReliability score
1Suzuki97.8%
2Honda95.8%
3Mini95.4%
4Alfa Romeo94.0%
5Tesla93.8%
6Vauxhall93.6%
7Kia93.5%
8Peugeot92.8%
9MG92.0%
10Mazda91.6%

And the bottom five:

PositionBrandReliability score
26Fiat/Abarth86.0%
27Volkswagen85.9%
28Jaguar85.8%
29Audi85.0%
30Land Rover84.9%

A few brands that readers often ask about sit in the middle of the table: Lexus is 12th on 90.7%, Hyundai joint 14th on 90.3%, Toyota 17th on 89.7%, BMW 19th on 89.5%, Mercedes 21st on 88.6% and Ford 22nd on 88.4%. Toyota and Lexus are well known for reliability, but in this survey they did not top the table.

Suzuki also had the lowest share of cars with a fault: only 10% of the examples owners told What Car? about had any issues.

How the What Car? Survey Works

What Car? asks owners to report faults on their cars over the previous 24 months. The 2026 survey covers cars up to five years old and reports on the experiences of 39,332 owners, across 225 models from 30 brands. The rating weights the cost and time off the road more heavily than the number of faults, so a car with one expensive, long repair scores worse than a car with a few trivial ones. It is an open online survey of What Car? visitors and magazine subscribers, so it reflects people who chose to reply, not a random sample of every owner.

One more finding is worth knowing before you buy nearly-new: What Car? says only 81% of issues on cars up to five years old were fixed for free, down from 95% the year before.

Most Reliable Car Models 2026 (What Car?)

These are the top 10 models in the 2026 survey, with the years the generation was on sale.

PositionModelYearsReliability score
=1Mini Countryman2024-present100%
=1Suzuki Swift2017‑2024100%
3Toyota Aygo X2021-present99.7%
4BMW 4 Series Coupe and Convertible2020-present99.6%
5Mini hatchback2014‑202499.4%
=6Kia Niro hybrid and PHEV2016‑202299.3%
=6Lexus ES2018‑202699.3%
8Kia Niro hybrid and PHEV2022-present99.2%
9Hyundai i102020-present98.9%
10Mercedes E-Class2016‑202498.7%

Just outside the top 10 are the Honda ZR-V (2023 onwards) and Porsche Macan (2014 onwards), both on 98.6%. The Audi Q2 (2016 onwards) scores 98.5% and is the best small SUV. The MG S5 (2025 onwards) scores 98.3% and is the top electric SUV. Other scores quoted in the survey include the Honda Jazz on 97.1%, the petrol Vauxhall Corsa on 97.3% (with a 12% fault rate), the Nissan Leaf (2018-2024) on 95.9% and the Ford Fiesta, now discontinued, on 95.5%.

Least Reliable Models in the 2026 Survey

The lowest-scoring models are mostly large or complex SUVs. These are the ten lowest, starting from the bottom.

ModelYearsReliability score
Volkswagen Tiguan2024-present55.3%
Renault Arkana2021‑202558.5%
Mercedes GLE2019-present63.7%
Volkswagen ID.42021-present66.9%
Land Rover Discovery Sport2014-present68.2%
Jaecoo 72024-present71.9%
BMW X3 petrol2018‑202473.5%
Volkswagen Tiguan petrol2016‑202474.4%
Nissan Qashqai petrol2014‑202174.9%
Range Rover Evoque2019-present76.4%

Two caveats. The Jaecoo 7 result rests on a small sample: Jaecoo told Fleet World the result is based on responses about just 23 vehicles, seven of which had issues. Treat it as a pointer, not a verdict.

Second, some well-known models fall outside the bottom ten but still score poorly against their rivals. The Ford Focus (2018-2026) scored 85.6%, the Renault Zoe (2013-2024) scored 79.7%, which is the lowest in the electric car category, and the Peugeot 5008 (2017-2024) scored 79.3% with a 32% fault rate.

Car Reliability Index UK 2026 (Warrantywise)

What Car? covers cars up to five years old. If you are buying a car that is three to 15 years old, the Warrantywise Used Vehicle Reliability Index 2026 is more relevant. It was published in March 2026 and scores models out of 100, where a higher score means a lower risk of repairs.

How the Warrantywise Index Works

The index is built from repair claims on Warrantywise used car warranties, around 1.6 million data points between January 2023 and January 2026. It looks at repair frequency, average age, mileage and labour time. A model needs at least 250 vehicles on a plan to be included, and the index covers cars from 3 to 15 years old. Because it is based on claims, it reflects cars that were bought with a warranty from that company, which is not every car on the road. It is also not a survey of how people feel about their cars: it measures repair requests made under its warranty plans.

Warrantywise also reports that the average hourly labour rate in repair requests rose from £104.11 in 2023 to £112.30 in 2025, an increase of 7.87%. That is a reminder that a model with a poor score can be expensive to put right.

Warrantywise Top 10

RankModelReliability Index score
1Toyota Yaris89.2
2Kia Picanto86.8
3Toyota Aygo83.8
4Toyota RAV479.9
5Peugeot 10878.9
6Toyota Hilux78.4
7Citroen C178.0
8Suzuki Vitara78.0
9Kia Ceed77.5
10Suzuki Swift77.5

Warrantywise Bottom 10

Rank (lowest first)ModelReliability Index score
1Land Rover Discovery17.2
2BMW 7 Series18.7
3Mercedes S Class19.2
4Audi A719.2
5Land Rover Range Rover Velar19.7
6Land Rover Range Rover Sport21.1
7BMW X523.6
8Land Rover Discovery Sport24.1
9BMW X726.5
10Land Rover Defender 11028.0

The pattern is clear: small, simple cars at the top, and large, complex, expensive-to-fix cars at the bottom. The Suzuki Swift and Suzuki Vitara appear in the Warrantywise top 10 as well as in What Car?'s results, which is a useful cross-check. The Land Rover Discovery Sport is in the bottom ten here and also scores 68.2% in the What Car? survey.

Most Reliable Used Cars Over 5 Years Old

The What Car? 2026 survey stops at five years. The most recent What Car? list we found for older cars is the 2024 edition, based on 29,967 motorists and covering cars built between 1998 and 2018. It has not been updated for 2026, so treat it as a dated guide and not a current ranking. Scores are from the What Car? most reliable used cars 2024 list.

ModelYearsClassScore (2024 survey)
Audi A3 Saloon2013‑2020Executive100%
Kia Sportage diesel2016‑2018 registrationsFamily SUV100%
Lexus NX2014‑2021Family SUV99.6%
Mercedes SL2012‑2020Sports car99.1%
Lexus CT2011‑2021Family car98.9%
Lexus RX2009‑2016Luxury SUV98.6%
Honda Civic hatchback2012‑2017Family car98.4%
Lexus RX2016‑2022Luxury SUV98.1%
Mazda CX-52017-presentFamily SUV98.1%
Toyota Auris hatchback2013‑2019Family car97%

Read the small print. What Car? says no owner reported an issue on the Kia Sportage diesel, but only for cars registered between 2016 and 2018, and the later 2019-2021 cars were much less reliable. On the Mazda CX-5, the petrol is more reliable than the diesel. The lesson is to match the score to the exact year and engine, not just the badge.

The Warrantywise index above is the other useful guide for older cars, because it covers vehicles from 3 to 15 years old. Putting the two together, Toyota and Kia are the makes with models in both lists, which fits the common advice to look at simple, well-proven cars first.

J.D. Power Reliability 2026: Is There a UK Study?

Many people search for "J.D. Power reliability 2026 UK". As far as we can find, there is no 2026 J.D. Power reliability study for the UK. The most recent UK Vehicle Dependability Study we found was published on 9 May 2019. We could not find UK editions for 2020 to 2026, though that is based on our searches, not a statement from J.D. Power. The 2026 study that gets quoted is the US one.

J.D. Power UK 2019 (last UK edition found)

The 2019 UK Vehicle Dependability Study surveyed 11,530 owners of new vehicles registered between November 2015 and January 2018. It measures problems per 100 vehicles (PP100), so lower is better.

  • Peugeot ranked first overall on 77 PP100, followed by Skoda (88) and Hyundai (90).
  • Among premium brands, Volvo ranked first on 106 PP100, ahead of Mercedes-Benz on 136.

These are very old figures. The cars involved are now at least eight years old, and the brands have changed since.

J.D. Power US 2026 (US owners only)

The 2026 US Vehicle Dependability Study was published on 12 February 2026. It covers 33,268 original owners of 2023 model-year vehicles after three years of ownership, in the United States.

  • The industry average was 204 PP100.
  • Among premium brands, Lexus ranked first on 151 PP100, then Cadillac (175) and Porsche (182).
  • Among mass-market brands, Buick ranked first on 160 PP100, then Mini (168) and Chevrolet (178).
  • The Lexus IS was the top model overall.
  • By powertrain, petrol cars averaged 198 PP100, hybrids 213, battery electric 237 and plug-in hybrids 281.

These are US-market cars, sold under US brand lineups, so do not read them as a UK ranking. They do show one trend that matches UK complaints: infotainment and phone connectivity are the most common problem area.

Most Reliable Cars in Europe: ADAC 2026

The best European data on breakdowns comes from Germany. The ADAC, Germany's motoring club, publishes the Pannenstatistik 2026, based on breakdowns it attended during 2025. It covers 158 model series from 27 makes, on cars aged two to nine years (first registered from 2016 to 2023).

Some caveats first. This is German data. It counts only breakdowns attended by the ADAC and leaves out tyre defects and breakdowns the driver caused. Importantly, the ADAC does not publish a ranking, and we could not verify per-model breakdown figures, so what follows are the names it lists, not scores. It does say 74 model series came out as extremely reliable overall, and 16 were unreliable in individual years.

Named as best in class include:

  • Small cars: Mazda 2, Skoda Fabia, Seat Ibiza, Suzuki Swift, Suzuki Vitara, VW Polo, Renault Zoe
  • City cars: Toyota Aygo, Suzuki Ignis, Skoda Citigo, VW up!, Dacia Spring
  • Compact: Audi A3, BMW 1 Series, Mazda CX-5, Mercedes A-Class, MG4, Skoda Karoq, Volvo XC40, VW Golf, VW Tiguan
  • Mid-size: Audi A4, BMW 3 Series, Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model Y, VW Passat, Skoda Enyaq
  • Upper mid-size: BMW 5 Series, BMW X5, Mercedes GLE, VW Arteon

Named as worst in class (with the first-registration years it flags) include: Toyota Yaris (2021-2023), Toyota Yaris Cross (2022-2023), Toyota Corolla (2023), Toyota C-HR (2020-2022), Toyota RAV4 (2017-2022), Mazda 3 (2020), Mazda CX-30 (2020), Nissan Qashqai (2019), Ford Kuga (2021), Hyundai Ioniq 5 (2022-2023) and Opel Insignia (2016-2019 and 2022).

What the ADAC Says About Breakdowns Overall

  • Breakdowns are falling. For a five-year-old car, the breakdown probability went from 3.6% in 2015 to 2.1% in 2025. For a ten-year-old car it went from 6.5% to 3.1%.
  • Electric cars broke down less often than combustion cars. Among two-year-old cars in 2025 there were 2.1 breakdowns per 1,000 electric vehicles against 5.8 for combustion cars. For five-year-old cars it was 10.3 against 17.4, so electric cars were 40% lower.
  • The 12V starter battery caused 45.4% of breakdowns in 2025, up slightly from 44.9% the year before. Engine and engine management caused 21.8%.

Why the Sources Disagree

The same Toyota Yaris is the most reliable used car in the Warrantywise index, yet some of its years are listed among the worst in class by the ADAC. That is not a contradiction. The sources measure different things.

  • Owner surveys (What Car?) capture any fault an owner remembers in 24 months, weighted by cost and time off the road. Fresh cars with tech problems score badly even if they never leave you stranded.
  • Warranty claims (Warrantywise) capture repair requests on cars aged three to 15. That favours simple, cheap-to-fix cars and punishes complex luxury cars, where one repair costs a lot.
  • Breakdown data (ADAC) counts roadside call-outs. The 12V battery causes nearly half of these, so a car with a fussy or weak starter battery looks poor even though the engine and gearbox are fine. The Yaris and RAV4 entries fit that pattern, and Warrantywise ranks the Yaris first (89.2) and the RAV4 fourth (79.9) on UK warranty data.
  • Brand versus model: Toyota is a good example. It is 17th as a brand in the What Car? survey (89.7%), yet it holds four places in the Warrantywise top ten. Brand averages hide strong and weak models, and a single engine can change the picture.
  • New versus old cars: a car that scores well at two years old tells you little about the same car at ten, and the reverse is also true.

The practical answer is to shortlist models that do well in more than one source, then check the specific year and engine. The Suzuki Swift and Suzuki Vitara are the clearest examples in this guide, appearing in What Car?, Warrantywise and ADAC lists at once.

FREE INSTANT CHECK

A reliable model is an average. Check the car you are viewing.

Every table above scores thousands of cars. The one on the forecourt may be the neglected one, and its records are instant by reg.

MOT history and the mileage at every test, free, so a jump or a fall stands out
Any open DVSA recall, free
Finance still owed, a write-off record, a stolen marker and how many keepers it has had, in the full report

Free instant check · Not happy? We will refund you

What the Official MOT Data Shows

The MOT is the only official, nationwide check on cars, and DVSA publishes the headline results. Using the DVSA MOT testing data for Great Britain, cars and light vans (classes 3 and 4) had an initial fail rate of 27.51% in the 2025-26 financial year, across 33,310,534 tests.

That means roughly 72.5% passed first time. Note that this is our own calculation (100 minus the fail rate), not a figure DVSA publishes, and it includes light vans as well as cars. The trend is improving:

PeriodInitial fail rate (classes 3 and 4)
2016‑1735.40%
2024‑2528.08%
2025‑2627.51%
April to June 202626.75%

The final fail rate for 2025-26, after retests, was 22.30%.

There is no official table of MOT pass rates by make or model. The GOV.UK data is by vehicle class and by type of defect, and it is described as not classed as an official statistic. Make and model analysis needs the raw anonymised MOT files published on data.gov.uk, and the latest one we found covers 2023 results. Our MOT pass rates by model page shows first-time pass rates we calculated from that raw DVSA data, with the method set out.

How to Check the Reliability of the Car You Are Viewing

A model score is an average across thousands of cars. The car on the forecourt is one of them, and it could have been looked after or neglected. These checks take little time and tell you far more.

  1. MOT history. Use the free GOV.UK MOT history check. Look for repeated advisories on the same item, such as corrosion, suspension or brakes, and failures that were fixed only at the last minute. Our MOT history check guide explains how to read it, and you can also use our MOT history check.
  2. Service records. Look for regular servicing at the intervals the manufacturer sets, and evidence of big jobs such as a timing belt change where one is due. If the records are missing, see how to recover a missing service history.
  3. Recalls. Check for outstanding safety recalls on the GOV.UK vehicle recall checker. A recall that was never done is a reason to ask questions. Our outstanding recall guide explains what to do.
  4. A history check. A reliable model is no use if the car has outstanding finance, a write-off record or a stolen marker. A history check shows finance, write-off and stolen records from Experian, plus the mileage recorded at each MOT test so you can spot a jump or a fall. It does not verify the mileage, so treat it as a clue to follow up. You can run a free check first, or see the full history check.
  5. Test drive and inspection. Check for warning lights, listen for knocks and whines, and make sure the gearbox changes smoothly. Use our test drive checklist, and pay for an independent inspection if a hidden fault would be costly.

On a hybrid or electric car, also ask about the condition of the high-voltage battery, and see our EV battery health guide. Since the 12V battery causes so many breakdowns in the ADAC data, ask how old the small battery is, whatever the fuel type.

For buying with a warranty, see our car warranty guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most reliable car in the UK?

It depends on the age of the car and the survey. In the 2026 What Car? survey the Mini Countryman and Suzuki Swift tied on 100%. In the Warrantywise index, which covers cars aged 3 to 15, the Toyota Yaris leads on 89.2 out of 100.

What is the most reliable car brand in the UK in 2026?

Suzuki, on 97.8% in the 2026 What Car? Reliability Survey of cars up to five years old. Honda (95.8%) and Mini (95.4%) are second and third. Land Rover was last of the 30 brands on 84.9%.

What is the car reliability ranking for 2026?

There is no single official ranking. The main UK ones are the What Car? survey (owners, cars up to five years old) and the Warrantywise Reliability Index (repair claims, cars aged 3 to 15). The tables above show both in full.

Is there a J.D. Power reliability study for the UK in 2026?

Not that we can find. The last UK Vehicle Dependability Study we found was published in 2019, when Peugeot ranked first on 77 PP100. The 2026 J.D. Power study is US-only, where the industry average was 204 PP100.

What are the most reliable second hand cars in the UK?

For used cars aged 3 to 15, the Warrantywise top five are the Toyota Yaris, Kia Picanto, Toyota Aygo, Toyota RAV4 and Peugeot 108. Small, simple cars dominate, while large premium SUVs and saloons fill the bottom ten.

What are the most reliable used cars over 5 years old?

The most recent What Car? list we found for older cars is the 2024 edition, where the Audi A3 Saloon (2013-2020) and the Kia Sportage diesel (2016-2018 registrations) scored 100%, followed by the Lexus NX on 99.6%. Warrantywise also covers cars up to 15 years old.

What are the most reliable cars in Europe?

The ADAC publishes German breakdown data for cars aged two to nine, but no ranking. It names models such as the Suzuki Swift, Mazda 2, VW Golf and Tesla Model 3 as best in class. Electric cars had 2.1 breakdowns per 1,000 at two years old against 5.8 for combustion cars.

What percentage of cars pass the MOT first time?

Based on DVSA data, the initial fail rate for cars and light vans was 27.51% in 2025-26, so about 72.5% passed first time. That pass rate is our own calculation and includes light vans.

Conclusion

Use the surveys to build a shortlist: Suzuki, Honda, Mini and Kia do well with owners of newer cars, and small Toyota, Kia and Suzuki models do well in warranty claims on older ones. Be more cautious with large premium SUVs, which fill the bottom of the Warrantywise index, and several of which, such as the Mercedes GLE and Land Rover Discovery Sport, are in What Car?'s bottom ten.

Then judge the actual car. A well-kept example of an average model is a better buy than a neglected example of a reliable one, so check the MOT history, the service records and recalls, and run a history check before you view.

Scores and rankings change every year. The figures here were checked on 28 October 2026, so look for newer editions of each survey.

Sources

FREE INSTANT CHECK

Found a car from this list? Check it before you buy.

Free: MOT history, mileage and recalls. Finance, write-off and theft are in the full report.

Free instant check · Not happy? We will refund you

About this article

Written and reviewed by the Carhealth Editorial Team. Our guides are researched using manufacturer data, DVLA records, industry data, and real-world owner experience. We update articles when regulations or market conditions change.