Industry News

Car Finance Scandal: FCA Compensation Scheme Explained

Where the FCA car finance compensation scheme stands in late 2026: who is eligible, the £830 average, the legal challenge, and what used car buyers should check.

By the Carhealth Editorial TeamUpdated 12 min read

FREE INSTANT CHECK

Hidden finance? Check before you buy.

The Free Report does not include finance. The finance check is in the full report.

Free instant check · Not happy? We will refund you

Introduction

If you bought a car on finance between 2007 and 2024, you may have heard that you could be owed money. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has set up an industry-wide compensation scheme for car finance customers who were treated unfairly because of how dealers and brokers were paid commission.

This guide explains what happened, where the scheme stands as of late October 2026, who is likely to be eligible, and what it means if you are buying a used car today. Things are still moving, so always check the FCA's car finance complaints page for the latest position before you act.

The short version, from the FCA's own figures:

  • The scheme covers car, van, motorbike and campervan finance agreements taken out between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024.
  • The FCA estimates around 12.1 million agreements are eligible, roughly 37% of the agreements in that period.
  • The FCA expects an average of around £830 per agreement. Some people will get more, some less, and many people who had car finance will get nothing.
  • Parts of the scheme have been suspended because of a legal challenge, which is due to be heard in early 2027. Until that is settled, lenders do not have to calculate or pay compensation.
  • You do not need a claims management company or law firm to take part.

What was the car finance scandal about?

Most car finance in the UK is arranged by the dealer, who acts as a credit broker between you and the lender. The dealer is paid commission by the lender for arranging the deal.

The problem was how some of that commission worked. Under a discretionary commission arrangement (DCA), the lender let the dealer or broker set the interest rate within a range. The higher the rate the dealer chose, the more commission the dealer earned. Customers were usually not told that the dealer could raise their rate to earn more, so many paid more interest than they needed to.

The FCA banned discretionary commission arrangements in motor finance from 28 January 2021. The redress scheme deals with what happened before that, and with two other kinds of unfairness that continued after it.

What the scheme covers

According to the FCA, an agreement may be eligible if it involved one of these:

  1. A discretionary commission arrangement, where the broker could adjust your interest rate to earn more commission.
  2. A high commission arrangement, where the commission was at least 39% of the total cost of credit and at least 10% of the loan.
  3. A contractual tie, where the broker used only one lender or gave one lender first refusal, and this was not made clear to you. The FCA excludes cases where the link between the lender, manufacturer and dealer was obvious, such as a shared or similar name.

Hire purchase (HP) and personal contract purchase (PCP) agreements are both in scope. Personal contract hire (leasing) is not.

How we got here: the timeline

DateWhat happened
28 January 2021The FCA ban on discretionary commission arrangements in motor finance takes effect
11 January 2024The FCA announces a review of historical motor finance commission and pauses the deadline for firms to answer DCA complaints
25 October 2024The Court of Appeal rules against lenders in three cases (Johnson, Wrench and Hopcraft) on undisclosed commission
1 August 2025The Supreme Court overturns most of the Court of Appeal's reasoning, but finds the relationship in the Johnson case was unfair under the Consumer Credit Act 1974
October 2025The FCA consults on an industry-wide redress scheme
30 March 2026The FCA publishes its final rules (policy statement PS26/3)
2026The scheme is challenged in the courts and parts of it are suspended
Early 2027The legal challenge is due to be heard

The Supreme Court ruling mattered because it narrowed the legal basis for claims. It did not say every hidden commission was unlawful. Instead, courts look at whether the overall relationship between lender and borrower was unfair, taking into account things like the size of the commission and what the customer was told. That is why the final scheme focuses on the three types of arrangement above rather than on every finance deal.

Where the scheme stands now (October 2026)

The FCA's final rules set out how lenders should review agreements and work out compensation. Lenders were given dates to respond to people who had already complained:

  • Agreements from 1 April 2014, complained about by 30 June 2026: lenders were due to respond by 18 November 2026.
  • Agreements before 1 April 2014, complained about by 31 August 2026: lenders were due to respond by 18 January 2027.

However, the scheme has since been legally challenged, and the FCA says parts of it are suspended. On its consumer page the FCA says the challenge was due to be heard between 16 February and 3 March 2027, and on 26 October 2026 it noted that the Tribunal had extended the hearing dates. Until the legal process ends, lenders do not need to calculate or pay compensation.

If the scheme is upheld and the judgment is not appealed, the FCA expects payments to start in 2027. Nobody can promise a date before then.

How much compensation could you get?

The FCA estimates an average of around £830 per eligible agreement. Industry reports put the total redress the FCA expects lenders to pay at around £7.5 billion, lower than the figure in the October 2025 consultation.

Individual amounts depend on your agreement: how much you borrowed, the interest rate, the commission paid and how long the agreement ran. The FCA's rules set out a formula that lenders must follow, including an interest element for the time you have been without the money. Be wary of anyone who quotes you a precise figure before your lender has looked at your agreement.

Some important points:

  • Not everyone with car finance is owed money. If your deal had a flat commission that was not unusually high and there was no hidden tie, you are unlikely to be eligible.
  • You cannot get paid twice. If a court has already decided your claim, that agreement is excluded from the scheme. If you have started legal action that has not reached court, the lender can pause its review and ask how you want to proceed.
  • Tax: the refund of interest you overpaid is generally not taxable, but any interest added to compensation may count as savings income. Check HMRC's guidance on tax on savings interest if you receive a payment.

FREE INSTANT CHECK

Hidden finance? Check before you buy.

The Free Report does not include finance. The finance check is in the full report.

Free instant check · Not happy? We will refund you

Do you need to do anything?

Check whether you had car finance in the period

Look for old finance paperwork, emails from the lender or annual statements. If you cannot find them, your credit file may list past agreements, though older ones may have dropped off. You can ask the lender for details of your agreement.

Complain to the lender directly

You can complain to the lender yourself, for free. Many lenders have an online form. Include your name, address at the time, the car's registration if you remember it, and the approximate date of the agreement. If you are unhappy with the lender's final response, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service, again for free, within the time limit stated in the lender's letter.

Think hard before signing up with a claims firm

The FCA says you do not need a claims management company or law firm to take part, and warns that you could pay fees of up to 36% including VAT for a service you do not need. If you have already signed up and want to leave, read the cancellation terms carefully.

Watch out for scams

High-profile compensation schemes attract fraudsters. Neither the FCA nor your lender will ask you to pay a fee upfront to release compensation, and you should never share bank login details. If you think you have been targeted, report it to Report Fraud, which replaced Action Fraud in December 2025.

What if your lender no longer exists?

Some lenders have been bought, renamed or closed since 2007. Claims against a lender that was bought are usually handled by the firm that took over its book. If a lender has failed, any claim may be dealt with by its administrator, and you should not assume the Financial Services Compensation Scheme will cover it.

What this means if you are buying a used car

The compensation scheme does not change the rules on buying a car that still has finance on it, but the publicity has made many buyers more aware of car finance generally. These are the points that matter when you are buying.

Outstanding finance on the car you are buying

A car bought on HP or PCP belongs to the lender until the agreement is paid off. If the seller has not cleared it, the finance stays attached to the agreement, not to you. The debt never transfers to the buyer.

If you are a private buyer (not a motor trader) and you buy in good faith, without knowing about a hire purchase or conditional sale agreement, Part III of the Hire Purchase Act 1964 usually gives you good title to the car. That protection does not cover trade buyers, and it does not cover logbook loans (bills of sale). Even when the law is on your side, you may face a stressful dispute with the lender while you prove you bought in good faith. Our guide to buying a car with outstanding finance explains how this works in practice.

Stolen cars are different. If the car turns out to be stolen, you generally do not get good title under section 21 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979, even if you paid a fair price. See what to do if you bought a stolen car in good faith.

Dealer finance today

The DCA ban means dealers can no longer adjust your rate to earn more commission, and FCA rules require them to tell you about commission and any ties to lenders. When you are offered finance:

  • Ask what commission the dealer receives and whether they work with one lender or several.
  • Compare the APR and the total amount payable with a quote from your bank or another lender.
  • Do not let a low monthly payment distract you from the total cost or a large final balloon payment.
  • Never feel pushed into signing on the day.

Checks before you buy

Whoever you buy from, check the car's history before you pay:

  1. Outstanding finance: a history check shows whether a finance agreement is recorded against the car, using records from Experian.
  2. Stolen and write-off records: also from Experian, drawing on police and insurer theft records.
  3. MOT history: from DVSA, including recorded mileage at each test. Compare the readings over time. A reading that goes backwards or a long gap is worth asking about.
  4. The V5C logbook: make sure the seller's name and address match, and the VIN on the logbook matches the car.
  5. An independent inspection: for an expensive car, a mechanic's inspection can find faults a paper check cannot.

You can check the car first, then get a full report with 25 checks and instant results before you hand over any money.

Frequently asked questions

Is the car finance compensation scheme open?

The FCA has published its final rules, but parts of the scheme are suspended because of a legal challenge due to be heard in early 2027. Check the FCA's car finance complaints page for the latest position.

Which agreements are covered?

Car, van, motorbike and campervan finance agreements taken out between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024 that involved a discretionary commission arrangement, high commission or an undisclosed tie with the lender. Personal contract hire (leasing) is not covered.

How much will I get?

The FCA's estimate is an average of around £830 per eligible agreement. Your amount depends on your agreement, and you may not be owed anything.

When will payments be made?

The FCA expects payments to start in 2027 if the scheme is upheld and the judgment is not appealed.

Do I need a claims company?

No. You can complain to your lender for free and, if needed, go to the Financial Ombudsman Service for free.

Can a finance company take a car I bought privately?

If you are a private buyer who bought in good faith without knowing about an HP or conditional sale agreement, the Hire Purchase Act 1964 usually protects you. It can still lead to a dispute, so check for finance before you buy.

Conclusion

The car finance compensation scheme is real, but it is smaller and slower than early headlines suggested. The FCA expects around 12.1 million agreements to be eligible, with an average of about £830 each, and payments are on hold until the legal challenge is resolved. If you think you were affected, complain to your lender directly and keep an eye on the FCA's updates rather than paying a claims firm.

If you are buying a used car, the scandal is a reminder to understand finance before you sign and to check the car's history before you pay.

This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Last checked against the FCA's consumer guidance on 28 October 2026.

FREE INSTANT CHECK

Hidden finance? Check before you buy.

The Free Report does not include finance. The finance check is in the full report.

Free instant check · Not happy? We will refund you

About this article

Written and reviewed by the Carhealth Editorial Team. Our guides are researched using manufacturer data, DVLA records, industry data, and real-world owner experience. We update articles when regulations or market conditions change.